Subscribe to our newsletter

waffi live
Premier League Records Joint~High Six Refereeing Errors In Single Weekend
7069
7025
19/11/2569 08:45:03
3256
18/11/2026, 18:49:41
By JAMES OTUBO - 18/11/2026, 19:09:49
views 7077
The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel has identified six incorrect on-field decisions during the latest round of fixtures, equalling its highest number of refereeing errors recorded in a single weekend. The five-member panel reviews controversial incidents after every round of matches, assessing whether referees and video assistant referees (VAR) made the correct decisions. The last time the panel recorded six on-field errors was during the early stages of the 2023-24 season. However, the figure excludes correct VAR interventions that overturned mistakes, including the red card shown to Brentford striker Igor Thiago. Almost every fixture in the latest round featured a disputed refereeing decision, triggering widespread debate among players, clubs and supporters. The controversies began on Friday when Coventry City were denied a potential penalty after Everton defender James Tarkowski appeared to pull Caleb Yirenkyi's hair inside the penalty area. Arsenal were also refused a penalty following a VAR review that ruled Kai Havertz offside, while Tottenham subsequently lodged a formal complaint over Jayden Bogle's challenge on their player, Mathys Tel, which did not result in a red card. Liverpool, meanwhile, questioned the decision to award Crystal Palace a late penalty. Despite the widespread criticism, the KMI Panel identified only two incidents where both the referee's original decision and VAR assessment were incorrect. **Two incidents ruled incorrect by both referee and VAR** **Incident 1:** Coventry City's Caleb Yirenkyi appeared to have his hair pulled by Everton's James Tarkowski inside the penalty area. However, the referee did not award a penalty. **KMI Panel verdict:** Unanimous 5-0 vote against both the on-field decision and VAR. The panel said Tarkowski clearly held Yirenkyi's hair and agreed that VAR should have intervened to award a penalty. **Incident 2:** Arsenal's Kai Havertz was brought down inside the box by Hull City defender Nobel Mendy. VAR official Michael Oliver advised referee Farai Hallam to review the incident on the pitchside monitor, but a penalty was not awarded because Havertz was considered offside. **KMI Panel verdict:** Unanimous 5-0 vote against both the referee's decision and VAR. According to the panel, although Havertz was in an offside position, Mendy had already committed a clear and significant holding offence before the potential offside infringement. **Four decisions criticised by the panel but not VAR** The KMI Panel assesses refereeing incidents from two separate perspectives: whether the referee made the correct decision under the laws of the game and whether VAR should have intervened. While an on-field decision may be judged incorrect, it does not automatically mean VAR was expected to overturn it. The intervention threshold, available footage and referee's explanation are also considered. **Incident 1:** Everton's Thierno Barry scored against Coventry City in the 61st minute, but the goal was subjected to a VAR review over a possible handball. **KMI Panel verdict:** A 3-2 majority considered the on-field decision incorrect, while all five members agreed that VAR was right not to intervene. The panel concluded that the ball probably struck Barry's hand accidentally but said the available footage did not provide sufficient evidence to overturn the decision. **Incident 2:** Crystal Palace were awarded a stoppage-time penalty against Liverpool following contact between Milos Kerkez and Dario Osorio, three minutes into added time. **KMI Panel verdict:** Unanimous 5-0 vote against the on-field penalty decision, but unanimous support for VAR not to intervene. The panel believed the contact was unavoidable and therefore did not justify a penalty, although it did not consider the referee's decision a clear and obvious error. **Incident 3:** Ipswich Town received a 72nd-minute penalty against Bournemouth after Lewis Cook was adjudged to have fouled Abdoul Ouattara. **KMI Panel verdict:** A 4-1 majority ruled the on-field decision incorrect, while four members agreed that VAR should not have intervened. The panel said Ouattara deliberately stepped across Cook, who had not attempted a challenge, but maintained that the incident did not meet the threshold for a VAR correction. **Incident 4:** Bournemouth midfielder Marcus Tavernier was involved in a potential second-yellow-card incident. **KMI Panel verdict:** A 3-2 majority considered the referee's decision incorrect, with no possibility of VAR intervention. The panel said Tavernier had deliberately delayed the restart of play. **Controversial decisions the panel upheld** Several high-profile incidents that attracted widespread criticism during the weekend were ultimately considered correctly handled by the match officials and VAR. **Incident 1:** Leeds United's Jayden Bogle caught Tottenham's Mathys Tel around the ankle during a challenge, but VAR did not recommend a red card. **KMI Panel verdict:** A 3-2 majority backed the referee's decision and VAR's assessment. Most panel members believed Bogle was attempting to challenge for the ball and that his trailing leg made contact with Tel without sufficient speed, force or intensity to constitute serious foul play. However, two members felt the challenge warranted a dismissal. **Incident 2:** Chelsea's Cole Palmer went down near the edge of the penalty area following a challenge by Sunderland's Luke O'Nien. **KMI Panel verdict:** A 4-1 majority supported the on-field decision and VAR's handling of the incident. The panel agreed that O'Nien made contact with Palmer and that a free-kick should have been awarded because the offence occurred outside the penalty area. One member, however, believed the contact happened inside the box. **Incident 3:** Sunderland were awarded a penalty after Chelsea defender Levi Colwill was adjudged to have tripped Brian Bobbey. **KMI Panel verdict:** Unanimous 5-0 support for the referee and VAR. The panel explained that both players were holding each other as they entered the penalty area before Colwill committed a careless trip. **Incident 4:** Manchester United goalkeeper Senne Lammens was accused of fouling Aston Villa goalkeeper Zion Suzuki before Patrick Dorgu's 96th-minute equaliser. **KMI Panel verdict:** Unanimous 5-0 support for the on-field decision and VAR. The panel ruled that although Lammens turned away from the ball, his contact with Suzuki was not significant enough to constitute an offence. **What the latest findings mean for VAR** The KMI Panel was discontinued in the Scottish Premiership during the summer following growing dissatisfaction among clubs over its voting decisions. However, it remains an important part of the Premier League's refereeing system, with its assessments contributing to a performance table that determines 50 per cent of referees' bonus payments. Although supporters may argue that more than two VAR errors occurred during the latest round of fixtures, the panel's responsibility is not to reflect public opinion but to assess incidents against the laws of the game and the Premier League's refereeing standards. Nevertheless, six incorrect on-field decisions, alongside the separate VAR intervention involving Thiago's red card, represent a significant number of officiating controversies in one weekend. The findings are also likely to intensify the debate over VAR, particularly among supporters who question why refereeing mistakes are sometimes allowed to stand despite the availability of video technology. The disagreement surrounding the high threshold for VAR intervention continues to fuel frustration with the system.
Source: WAFFI TV News
Full image
Install WAFFITV