Four Possible Next Steps For The Premier League After Man City Ruling
If you thought the long-running saga surrounding Manchester City’s 115 charges was finally coming to an end, think again.
Two years and 10 days after the hearing began, and 1,329 days since City were first charged, a verdict has now been reached, with the club found guilty of the majority of the alleged financial rule breaches.
However, the development did not come directly from the Premier League or Manchester City. Instead, The Athletic first reported the verdict.
BBC Sport was subsequently informed that the decision had been sent to club executives during the week, with those given access to the document required to sign non-disclosure agreements before opening it.
A process can appear completely secure, as this one undoubtedly had, but expanding the number of people with access inevitably increases the possibility of information being leaked.
Despite that, the Premier League has continued to remain publicly silent.
Manchester City also stopped short of confirming whether the club had been found guilty. In a statement that acknowledged an appeal is expected, City made clear that, from their perspective, the “process remains ongoing.”
All of this suggests that the long-awaited ruling from the independent panel may not represent the conclusion of the case. Instead, it could mark the end of only the first stage of what promises to be a much longer process.
The uncertainty surrounding the case now appears likely to intensify.
Manchester City supporters, along with the wider football community, are left wondering what punishment the club could face and when the entire matter will finally reach a definitive conclusion.
Given the seriousness of the charges, a points deduction now appears to be a possible outcome, although any punishment would remain subject to City’s appeal. The club has consistently maintained that it has done nothing wrong.
When and how any sanction is imposed could have significant consequences not only for Manchester City but for the Premier League as a whole.
There is also the possibility of other clubs seeking compensation from City, adding another potential complication to the case.
Enzo Maresca’s side are due to face Liverpool on 11 October when the Premier League resumes following the international break. A victory could see them move six points clear at the top of the table.
But could the ongoing case ultimately make that position meaningless?
There are several possible scenarios from here, and none offers a straightforward outcome.
**Scenario one: No punishment announced this season**
Determining the punishment should be quicker than establishing guilt, but little about Manchester City’s case has followed a straightforward timeline.
Because City have denied the charges, the case will now proceed to a sanction hearing before the independent panel. BBC Sport understands the hearing could still be months away, while the outcome may not be published until the club’s appeal is concluded.
The panel will consider the full range of possible sanctions, including fines, points deductions and relegation.
The situation differs from Chelsea’s case earlier this year. Chelsea self-reported the breaches and admitted wrongdoing, allowing the club to negotiate a sanction with the Premier League. City could theoretically pursue a similar agreement, but their long-standing denials make that appear unlikely.
The panel will have to examine hundreds of pages of evidence before deciding the appropriate punishment. Everton were initially deducted 10 points for PSR breaches before the penalty was reduced to six on appeal, and later received another two-point deduction in a separate case. Nottingham Forest were deducted four points.
City, however, face seven separate PSR-related charges in the Premier League, alongside five further charges concerning UEFA competitions. The case also includes allegations relating to sponsorship revenue, payments to players and managers, and failures to comply with investigations.
The scale and number of the charges could therefore result in a substantial points deduction if they are upheld, although the eventual punishment remains to be determined.
The timing creates another problem. If no sanction is imposed this season, questions will arise over the effect on the integrity of the competition, particularly if City win the title.
Coventry are currently third from bottom. If they are eventually relegated, there could be questions over whether the outcome would have been different had City’s punishment been imposed during the current campaign.
Backdating a points deduction to this season appears unlikely, leaving the Premier League with a difficult situation if the sanction process extends beyond the campaign.
A negotiated settlement could provide a quicker resolution, but it would require the Premier League and City to agree on a punishment, with the club presumably seeking to limit the severity of any sanction.
**Scenario two: Man City punishment is imposed this season but appealed**
The usual procedure when a points deduction is imposed is for the penalty to take immediate effect, subject to the club’s right to appeal.
For Manchester City, the punishment could be severe enough to effectively result in relegation. Alternatively, the club could face a substantial fine, although that would appear less likely given the use of points deductions in previous cases.
If City’s Premier League membership were revoked, however, it is unclear how such a sanction could be implemented in the middle of a season.
The key questions would then be when the punishment is announced and how quickly the appeal is resolved.
Premier League regulations set out timelines for appeals, but it remains unclear whether the usual process would apply directly to this case. Clubs normally have 14 days to appeal, although it is not known whether that period would begin once the sanction is formally issued or whether it has already started.
The league would usually seek an expedited appeal through the independent arbitration process that handles disciplinary cases. However, the complexity and scale of City’s case could make the process considerably less straightforward.
There is also a possibility, albeit a limited one, that the punishment would not affect the league table until the appeal has been decided.
That could trigger protests from clubs directly affected by the outcome, particularly those fighting for European qualification or against relegation, who could argue that the sanction should take immediate effect as is normally the case.
**Scenario three: Appeal is heard quickly and full decision announced**
For the integrity of the Premier League, clubs need clarity over the rules and consequences they are competing under, making a swift resolution the preferred outcome.
Last season, West Bromwich Albion were hit with a points deduction for breaching the profit and sustainability regulations, but the punishment was not announced until 24 April.
Although West Brom ultimately remained in the Championship, the late sanction dragged them back into the relegation battle and gave renewed hope to clubs fighting to avoid the drop.
The Premier League will be keen to avoid a similar situation, particularly if City’s punishment is not settled until the final stages of the season. However, given the complexity of the case, there is no guarantee of a quick resolution.
City could also successfully overturn the punishment on appeal, as they did when UEFA imposed a two-year Champions League ban on the club in July 2020.
However, unlike the UEFA case, Manchester City would not have the option of taking the Premier League case to the Court of Arbitration for Sport.
A successful appeal would be welcomed at the Etihad Stadium, but it would probably not bring an end to the wider dispute surrounding the case.
**Scenario four: Even after the case is closed, this is not over**
Premier League clubs are seeking legal advice over potential compensation claims against Manchester City arising from the case.
A source who previously held senior executive positions at two Premier League clubs told BBC Sport they expected individual clubs to pursue claims against City. Another leading lawyer suggested the Premier League could potentially coordinate the process on behalf of affected clubs.
Premier League rules allow clubs to take legal action against one another for compensation.
The issue has already been tested in the case involving Everton and Burnley. In June, Everton were ordered to pay Burnley £35m after breaching the Premier League’s profit and sustainability rules over a three-year period.
Burnley argued that Everton’s breach affected their chances of remaining in the Premier League and sought compensation for the financial losses associated with relegation. Everton are appealing the ruling, which they have said they will "robustly and thoroughly" contest.
That case could provide an important precedent for potential claims against City, although questions remain over whether there is a statute of limitations that would restrict how far back clubs can seek compensation.
Arsenal, Manchester United, Liverpool and Tottenham Hotspur reportedly took steps two years ago to preserve their rights to pursue claims.
Any potential action would extend beyond clubs that finished directly behind City in title races. Teams that missed out on Champions League qualification, failed to secure European football or were relegated could also argue that City’s alleged financial breaches affected their positions.
Claims could potentially cover lost prize money, European qualification revenue, match-day income, sponsorship bonuses and other commercial opportunities.
Professor Kieran Maguire of the University of Liverpool told BBC Sport that affected clubs could argue they were denied an opportunity.
He also noted that the Premier League’s traditional handbook does not explicitly reference a statute of limitations, although that could become the subject of a legal challenge from City.
The potential financial claims could be substantial. Maguire said Champions League qualification was worth at least £30m in prize money during the period in question, rising to around £60m-£70m by 2018.
Additional claims could involve lost gate receipts and sponsorship bonuses, while players at elite clubs could also have missed qualification-related bonuses.
The Manchester City case could therefore trigger a complex chain of consequences, ranging from points deductions and fines to potentially significant compensation claims from rival clubs.
For the Premier League, the dispute could become a much longer and more complicated process before everything is finally settled.
28/09/2026, 13:08:06
views 3967
6836