Wirtz Impresses, But Liverpool’s Tactical Dilemma Remains
Florian Wirtz delivered an influential performance as Liverpool returned to winning ways in the Premier League with victory over Brentford on Saturday, but questions remain over how best to accommodate the German playmaker in the team.
The 23-year-old has faced mounting criticism this season as he struggles to reproduce the form that convinced Liverpool to pay Bayer Leverkusen a club-record £116 million in June 2025.
Liverpool legend Steven Gerrard added to the debate this week, suggesting that Wirtz could benefit from being dropped temporarily to rebuild his confidence.
However, the midfielder offered a strong response at Brentford, producing an outstanding creative display that highlighted both his individual quality and the tactical questions surrounding Liverpool’s midfield structure.
Liverpool bounced back from their first league defeat of the season against Manchester City by scoring twice in the second half against Brentford, who had been reduced to 10 men before the interval.
The visitors took full advantage of their numerical superiority, registering 14 of their 21 attempts on goal after the break, with Wirtz playing a central role in their attacking efforts.
The Germany international created nine chances from open play, the highest total recorded by any player in a Premier League match over the past six seasons.
The last player to match that figure in a single league game was former Liverpool forward Sadio Mane, who created nine chances against Burnley in January 2021.
Wirtz also became the first player in more than 15 years to create nine chances in a Premier League away match, since Samir Nasri produced 10 for Manchester City against Tottenham in August 2011.
Despite those impressive numbers, debate continues over whether Liverpool’s current formation provides the right balance between attacking creativity and defensive security.
Former Liverpool midfielder and BBC Sport pundit Danny Murphy believes deploying Wirtz as a number 10, alongside two wingers, leaves too much responsibility on the central midfielders to cover space.
Reflecting on Liverpool’s performance, Murphy acknowledged the importance of securing an away victory but warned that the team remained vulnerable.
“They got the job done. First and foremost, that's another win on the road, which is always positive,” Murphy said.
“But I thought they looked too easy to play against. The spaces are too big.
“They're playing with two wingers and Wirtz at 10, so they're relying heavily on the two midfield players to try and cover so much space.
“It was too easy for Brentford to play out and to get in behind. That would be the biggest concern today for me.”
Wirtz’s attacking contribution, however, remains difficult to overlook.
Following his display at Brentford, he had created 18 chances in the Premier League this season, matching Brighton’s Pascal Gross for the highest total in the competition.
The playmaker also set up Victor Munoz to launch Liverpool’s comeback, recording assists in consecutive matches across all competitions for the first time since joining the club.
Nevertheless, the assist represented only his second goal involvement in seven league appearances this season.
His influence extended beyond the decisive moment, as he recorded a match-high 12 entries into the final third and completed 37 passes in that area of the pitch.
There were shortcomings in his overall performance, however. Only Milos Kerkez lost possession more frequently among Liverpool players, with Wirtz giving the ball away 19 times. He also won just one of his nine duels.
Murphy argued that Liverpool might benefit from strengthening their midfield rather than continuing with an attacking structure that leaves the team exposed.
“They don't look solid and don't look together in terms of shape,” he said.
“Instead of a number 10, where Wirtz is struggling to impact games, put three midfielders in.
“Always, the priority is foundation, defence, stability, being hard to beat. The other stuff can follow from there.
“At the moment, it just looks a little bit open. Against better teams, you're going to get hurt.”
The victory lifted Liverpool to fifth in the table, giving them three wins from their opening seven league matches under manager Andoni Iraola, who replaced Arne Slot during the summer.
It also marked Liverpool’s first away league victory after conceding the opening goal since December 2023, ending a 19-match winless run in such circumstances.
While striker Alexander Isak returned from injury, Liverpool suffered further setbacks, with Dominik Szoboszlai and Jeremie Frimpong both picking up injuries against Brentford.
Iraola acknowledged the challenge posed by Brentford’s home form and admitted that Liverpool had opportunities to make the closing stages more comfortable.
“When you come here, you see the results of Brentford at home and you have to be ready for this kind of battle,” he told BBC Sport.
“We had a lot of chances. Even at the end, we had some counters where we were three against one and need to finish. When we go 2-1, every throw-in and every free-kick can be a problem.”
The Liverpool manager also expressed concern about his squad’s fitness ahead of a demanding run of fixtures.
“We are in a delicate situation with some of the players. We were talking about this run of four games in 10 days, it's very, very demanding,” he said.
“We have to rest again because we have another big, big game against Villarreal in the Champions League on Tuesday.”
Wirtz’s performance at Brentford demonstrated his ability to unlock opposition defences, but Liverpool’s midfield balance remains a subject of debate. The challenge for Iraola will be finding a system that maximises the German’s creativity without compromising the team’s defensive stability.
17/10/2026, 22:03:13
views 3140
3457