Emergency Care: Doctors Reject Jail Bill, Threaten Nationwide Strike
The Nigerian Medical Association (NMA) and the Nigerian Association of Resident Doctors (NARD) have opposed a proposed amendment to the National Health Act that seeks to impose up to six months’ imprisonment or a N300,000 fine on doctors and other healthcare workers who deny or delay emergency medical treatment.
While the NMA warned that the proposed criminal sanctions could expose medical practitioners to unjust prosecution for circumstances beyond their control, NARD threatened nationwide industrial action if the National Assembly proceeded with the punitive provisions.
The two professional bodies argued that penalising healthcare workers without first addressing inadequate funding, poor hospital infrastructure, manpower shortages and the lack of essential medical supplies could worsen Nigeria’s healthcare challenges and encourage more medical professionals to leave the country.
Their opposition followed the passage for second reading of the National Health Act (Amendment) Bill, 2026, sponsored by Senator Abdulaziz Yar’Adua, representing Katsina Central Senatorial District.
The proposed legislation seeks to introduce mandatory standards for emergency medical treatment and referral procedures in public and private healthcare facilities across the country.
Under the bill, hospitals would be required to commence emergency assessments within 15 minutes of a patient's arrival and provide basic stabilisation measures, including oxygen therapy, intravenous fluids and pain relief, within 30 minutes.
It also provides for immediate life-saving interventions in critical situations and establishes timelines for transferring patients who require specialised medical attention.
Healthcare professionals and facilities found violating the proposed provisions could face a fine of up to N300,000, six months’ imprisonment or both.
The bill, which received the support of a majority of senators through a voice vote on Wednesday, has been referred to the Senate Committee on Tertiary and Primary Health for further legislative consideration and a public hearing.
Reacting to the development in a statement signed by its National Publicity Secretary, Prof. Olayinka Atilola, on Friday, the NMA acknowledged the good intentions behind the proposed legislation but urged lawmakers to consider the realities of healthcare delivery before introducing criminal penalties.
The association identified inadequate hospital infrastructure, insufficient medical personnel, shortages of essential medicines, faulty equipment, unreliable electricity and oxygen supplies, poor ambulance services and weak referral networks as major challenges affecting emergency healthcare delivery.
It questioned how hospitals with only one doctor attending to several critically ill patients, inadequate nursing staff and no functional oxygen supply could comply with the proposed 15-minute assessment and 30-minute stabilisation requirements.
The NMA also highlighted situations where emergency surgeries could be delayed because operating theatres were occupied, compatible blood was unavailable or specialists were not on duty.
Similarly, patients referred to tertiary healthcare facilities could experience delays due to unavailable ambulances, a lack of beds at receiving hospitals, insecurity and poor road infrastructure.
According to the association, these challenges represent the everyday realities of healthcare facilities, particularly in rural and underserved communities.
“The NMA is particularly concerned about the possibility of imposing criminal liability without sufficiently distinguishing between wilful professional misconduct and failures arising from institutional or systemic limitations,” the statement read.
“There is an important difference between a healthcare worker who deliberately abandons a patient despite having the capacity and resources to provide emergency care, and one who is unable to provide a particular intervention because the necessary equipment, personnel, medicines or infrastructure are unavailable.”
The association maintained that the inability to provide a particular medical intervention should not automatically be classified as professional negligence, stressing that criminal law should address culpable conduct rather than unfavourable clinical outcomes.
It further warned that enforcing rigid timelines without considering clinical circumstances and available resources could encourage defensive medical practices, unnecessary interventions and avoidable referrals instead of improving patient outcomes.
In a separate reaction, NARD described the proposed penalties as unjust and punitive, arguing that doctors should not be held criminally responsible for failures resulting from inadequate government funding, poor hospital facilities and insufficient personnel.
In a statement issued on Thursday, the association said it supported efforts to guarantee prompt emergency medical attention but would resist any legislation that criminalised healthcare workers for systemic failures beyond their control.
“It is unacceptable to punish doctors for the consequences of a healthcare system that successive governments have failed to adequately fund, equip and staff,” the association said.
NARD noted that medical practitioners were already contending with difficult working conditions, including obsolete equipment, inadequate manpower, unreliable electricity, shortages of emergency medical supplies and deteriorating hospital infrastructure.
Questioning the urgency attached to the proposed penalties, the association challenged the National Assembly to demonstrate similar commitment to addressing the country's persistent healthcare funding challenges.
It observed that Nigeria had continued to fall short of the 15 per cent health-sector budget allocation target contained in the Abuja Declaration.
The association urged lawmakers to prioritise adequate healthcare funding, functional emergency departments, modern diagnostic equipment, uninterrupted electricity, reliable ambulance services and sufficient medical personnel.
“You cannot legislate oxygen into an empty cylinder, electricity into a dark operating theatre, or life-saving equipment into an inadequately funded hospital,” it said.
NARD also challenged political officeholders to accept the same accountability standards they intend to impose on healthcare professionals.
It proposed that public officeholders should be required to seek medical treatment in Nigerian government hospitals, with appropriate sanctions for those who misuse public resources on avoidable overseas medical trips.
According to the association, the continued preference for foreign medical treatment by political leaders raises questions about their commitment to strengthening Nigeria's public healthcare system.
It further warned that introducing additional criminal penalties for already overstretched medical personnel could accelerate the migration of skilled healthcare workers under the Japa syndrome.
Although NARD acknowledged that the proposed amendment recognises resource limitations and circumstances beyond the control of medical practitioners, it maintained that the safeguards were inadequate unless they were made explicit, comprehensive and enforceable.
The association insisted that doctors should not face criminal prosecution over institutional failures, unavailable medical equipment, inadequate staffing or other circumstances beyond their reasonable control.
It therefore called on the National Assembly to withdraw and reconsider the punitive provisions, urging lawmakers to consult medical associations, hospital administrators
11/7/2026, 12:32:11 PM
views 6118
1079